Greenburgh Moves Forward With Townwide Reassessment

  • Comments (2)
Greenburgh's townwide reassessment will cover the unincorporated area and its six villages and will take about two and half years to complete. Photo Credit: Town of Greenburgh

GREENBURGH, N.Y. — Greenburgh hasn't had a townwide property revaluation since the 1950s, but the town board is making steps to change that.


Do you support a townwide property reassessment, Greenburgh?

View Results
Reader Results

Do you support a townwide property reassessment, Greenburgh?

  • Yes, my property needs a reassessment.

  • No, it will increase my taxes.

  • The town should have waited for a countywide reassessment.

Back to Vote

Town Assessor Edye McCarthy is preparing a Request for Proposals to solicit bids for outside corporations to conduct the townwide revaluation, which will cover both unincorporated Greenburgh and its surrounding villages. A bidder will be chosen by October and the reassessment will take two and a half years to complete, McCarthy said.

Greenburgh averages roughly 3,000 property assessment appeals every year — combine that with the Board of Assessment Review's reductions, certiorari and small-claims settlements, and the refunds amount to $10 million within Greenburgh for its taxing jurisdictions, McCarthy said. It's too premature to say how a reassessment will affect Greenburgh taxpayers, but a revaluation will illuminate property inequities in the community, she added.

"There's no way to tell what the impacts of taxes are going to be," McCarthy said. "With the town promoting a townwide reassessment, it will create equity among taxpayers."

Town Supervisor Paul Feiner pushed for a town reassessment after the Westchester County Executive office revealed in December that differences in property value assessments created a higher tax levy for 11 towns in 2013 and a lower levy for 14 towns. Greenburgh's tax levy increased by 2.1 percent even though the county budget's property tax levy did not change.

"A reassessment would stop the bleeding," Feiner said. "I would have preferred a countywide reassessment, but now we're going to do it on our own."

County legislators have weighed the idea of mandating a countywide reassessment every four years, and Assembly member Tom Abinanti (D-Greenburgh) introduced the Homeowners Relief Act in 2011 to  spearhead countywide revaluation by incentivizing local assessors to reassess properties using uniform standards.

A similar bill was approved by the County Board and both houses of the State Legislature in 1996, but was vetoed by then-Gov. George Pataki.

"This will help everyone because the town won't be giving away as much as we have been in tax grievances," Feiner said. "It's for long-term predictability and stability."

Greenburgh is still working with a dozen other communities in the county who are interested in a joint reassessment. Right now, the high-end price is set at about $4.5 million, but "the more communities we get, the cheaper it'll be," Feiner said.

Last year, Feiner joined Yonkers Mayor Mike Spano in sending letters to community leaders to participate in the reassessment. Spano confirmed in January the city has issued RFPs to conduct its first revaluation since 1954.

"That is money that could be used to build new schools, repair our streets and improve our parks," Spano wrote in his testimony for the state executive budget on Jan. 28.

  • 2

Comments (2)


Revaluation will never happen under Feiner’s watch. He'll continue to kick every can down the road. In the meantime, we'll lose over $100K at every Town Board meeting. He's got to go!


"Last year, Feiner joined Yonkers Mayor Mike Spano in sending letters to community leaders to participate in the reassessment. Spano confirmed in January the city has issued RFPs to conduct its first revaluation since 1954."

"Sending those letters" and partnering with other communities was another "fib" from Feiner since he claimed a savings in price due to combined buying power.
Meanwhile neighboring Scarsdale has almost finished its own reassessment not waiting for Feiner. This reassessment/revaluation is now in its third round of false "starts" under Feiner; the latest being two years ago.

Individual RFPs for and by individual communities are NOT an indication of combined buying power but the press releases from Feiner affirming this were picked up by the Daily Greenburgh in earlier stories -- duly noted and unquestioned.

Residents hope that not only will this current "interest" begin in earnest but also that the Town's Comprehensive Plan launched 4 years ago will finally see the light of day.

Interesting that despite communication with the firms already indicating their interest, the formal process of RFP will take until the end of October. By contrast, the RFP for the former Frank's Nursery site was but 90 days.
Hal Samis

In Other News